Cryptomustar
Wednesday, June 29, 2022
  • Home
  • Altcoin
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Litecoin
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Blockchain
  • Regulation
  • Market
  • Prices
  • ICO
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Altcoin
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Litecoin
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Blockchain
  • Regulation
  • Market
  • Prices
  • ICO
No Result
View All Result
Cryptomustar
No Result
View All Result
Home Market

DeFi Is Just Like the ICO Boom and Regulators Are Circling

by admin
August 24, 2020
in Market
0
DeFi Is Just Like the ICO Boom and Regulators Are Circling
0
SHARES
5
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Donna Redel is the former chairman of COMEX, a board member of New York Angels and an Adjunct Professor of Law at Fordham Law School. Olta Andoni is an Adjunct Professor at Chicago-Kent College of Law and Of Counsel at Zlatkin Wong, LLP. 

A corner of the crypto universe representing less than 1% of total market capitalization of crypto assets has been grabbing the headlines since June. This is the world of decentralized finance, or DeFi, which alternatively is referred to as the center of innovation, an experiment or the new wild, wild west where projects move fast and break things. 

A recent glance of articles on CoinDesk demonstrates the phenomenon. Once again, crypto headlines are focusing on the “craze,” the “frenzy of yield farming,” “investors pouring money into” and “another protocol going up in a fireball.” 

Will the nonstop headlines and framing around the “hot” new DeFi protocols chill the institutional adoption that is beginning in earnest for crypto, digital assets and blockchain technology? 

We believe that, at a minimum, the industry needs self-regulation. Without it, it is on a trajectory to serious regulatory scrutiny and reputational risk.

We are not the only ones to express concern about DeFi. Vitalik Buterin tweeted Aug. 14:

Also, Robert Leshner, the founder of Compound, a leading DeFi project, said of the yield farming craze recently:

As with almost everything in crypto, the strong sentiments and opinions make it difficult to determine the true essence and reality around the majority of DeFi projects. For us, this refrain is reminiscent of 2017’s frothy initial coin offering (ICO) days that ended badly for the good names of blockchain and crypto. 

There are certainly similarities: trading frenzy; projects emerging with little or no testing and without audit; no clear regulatory guidance and the recycling of ETH now leading to inflated gas prices. Are we on the precipice of one of the regulatory agencies waking up and sending a missive similar to The Dao Report? 

On the legal front, there is a lack of clear consensus about which agency should be regulating. And, again, there is a lack of guidance from multiple agencies that could be responsible for DeFi projects or for the space generally. 

We are alarmed and concerned with the apparent lack of 360-degree understanding of the potential role of the various actors or operators and their possible interactions with the projects, the governance and hence DeFi ecosystem. Tokens are appearing overnight. Projects are hesitant to use, or totally avoid, terminology that might infer “issue,” “issuance” or “issuer,” as these are hypersensitive words in the securities world. 

See also: What Is Yield Farming? The Rocket Fuel of DeFi, Explained

Calling a project an “experimental game” or an “innovation” is not sufficient to take it out of the regulatory ambit. The focus is shifting from securities regulation of “the issuer” and the Howey Test prevalent during the ICO days and after, to more complex analysis of the application of commodities regulation, questions relating to who is the “controlling stakeholder(s)” and whether liability or responsibility falls on them.  

Many questions, from a perspective of both securities law and commodities laws, should be examined anew to see how they may be applied to, as well as reimagined for, a disintermediated-decentralized financial model.  

The outstanding questions include whether the “controlling stakeholders” are determined by voting control on DeFi platforms, who among the investor group and founders who has voting control, and whether there should be standards for exchange listing. 

Furthermore, it remains to be seen whether defining these projects as  “decentralized” puts them outside of the regulatory reach or whether  the “centralized” ones should be referred to as “disintermediated finance” – aka the ability to conduct secure financial transactions directly, without the use of financial intermediaries. 

Calling a project an ‘experimental game’ or an ‘innovation’ is not sufficient to take it out of the regulatory ambit.

Despite the regulatory uncertainty, traders, projects and exchanges are going full steam ahead, with the result that tokens run high risks of unwarranted price changes, which impacts governance, liquidity and the well-being of the projects.

The mid-March meltdown of Maker was a warning to all about systemic risk and leverage. DeFi’s leverage and exposure to ETH has resulted in price escalation that compromised the governance voting for the projects, thereby necessitating a revamp of governance procedures. Some are optimistic about ETH’s rising price but are higher gas fees and network congestion compatible with DeFi’s long term goal of the democratization of finance?

In our view, the DeFi experiment demonstrates the need for creating a new set of industry rules: audits, proper risk disclosures and planning to anticipate what could go wrong before it actually happens. DeFi self-regulation should normalize collateral sufficiency reviews, auditing standards, governance both on an ongoing and crisis basis as well as the distribution-centralized ownership of tokens. 

A DeFi sandbox organized with the appropriate regulators would be a pathway to validation without excessive volatility or velocity of assets locked up principally due to “yield farming.” Experiments should grow at a measured pace which is the sandbox approach, where “experimental” projects would be launched  and the community’s participation would be monitored. 

See also: Redel/Andoni – A Safer Harbor: Improving Hester Peirce’s Proposal for Regulating Token Sales

An example of DeFi chaos is YAM, a project with an unaudited code, claiming to be a stablecoin, which made headlines for its rapid boom and bust all within 48 hours. With respect to stablecoins, we should remember regulators are still considering their status. Valerie Szczepanik, the Securities and Exchance Commission (SEC) senior adviser for digital assets, has said that certain types of stablecoins “…could raise issues under securities laws.” 

Additionally, the IOSCO (International Organizations of Securities Commissions) report indicated stablecoins could be securities. We need both specificity on a national and global level including from the G20.

Governance is central to many DeFi projects and definitely a component of regular finance that is looking for reformation. Unfortunately, crisis governance has become too frequent in DeFi. Many of these projects rely on governance protocols where a very small group of participants are able and/or pressured to change the protocol.  

It remains to be seen how a regulatory loophole in which these tokens are created, distributed and traded all without regulatory supervision will play out. At least with a modified Safe Harbor, proposed by Commissioner Hester Peirce, and which we commented on earlier this year, the SEC would have some oversight. For the moment, tokens in the DeFi are appearing daily and the explosion of tokens is leading to a distortion of purpose and “investors” are getting burned as projects implode.

Disclosure

The leader in blockchain news, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups.





Source link

RELATED POSTS

Young Web3 Believers Unfazed by Battered Crypto Market

Polkadot Chief Gavin Wood Announces Blockchain Governance Upgrade

Tags: BoomCirclingDeFiICORegulators
ShareTweetShare

Related Posts

Young Web3 Believers Unfazed by Battered Crypto Market

Young Web3 Believers Unfazed by Battered Crypto Market

by admin
June 29, 2022
0

In the Bay Area, a student pursuing a master’s program in software management at Carnegie Mellon University Silicon Valley...

Polkadot Chief Gavin Wood Announces Blockchain Governance Upgrade

Polkadot Chief Gavin Wood Announces Blockchain Governance Upgrade

by admin
June 29, 2022
0

Gov2 is set to launch on Kusama, Polkadot’s more nimble and experimental sister network, imminently, according to the blog...

What It’s Like to Work as a DAO Bounty Hunter

What It’s Like to Work as a DAO Bounty Hunter

by admin
June 29, 2022
0

Meet "T Wells," a 30-something former educator who, in 2021, began working for “bounties” (or gigs) in the DAO...

Bitcoin cae debajo de $20K en medio de preocupaciones por la inflación en España y signos de debilidad

Bitcoin cae debajo de $20K en medio de preocupaciones por la inflación en España y signos de debilidad

by admin
June 29, 2022
0

La inflación subió a 10% en España, un máximo de casi 37 años en ese país europeo, debilitando la...

Chainlink’s Smart Contract Products Go Live on Fantom

Chainlink’s Smart Contract Products Go Live on Fantom

by admin
June 29, 2022
0

Keepers is a decentralized transaction automation service and allows developers to automate any smart contract function using custom triggers....

POPULAR NEWS

4 Cryptocurrency that Blow Bitcoin Out of the Water

4 Cryptocurrency that Blow Bitcoin Out of the Water

September 25, 2020
Memoriae – Next Generation of Decentralized Cloud Storage Based on Blockchain

Memoriae – Next Generation of Decentralized Cloud Storage Based on Blockchain

July 1, 2021
Apollo CBDC: The CBDC Platform that can Power Economies

Apollo CBDC: The CBDC Platform that can Power Economies

October 6, 2020
Stratus: The Most Feature Rich Social Media Network

Stratus: The Most Feature Rich Social Media Network

September 9, 2020
Binance Coin (BNB) erupts above $270 as the whole Smart Chain ecosystem soars

Binance Coin (BNB) erupts above $270 as the whole Smart Chain ecosystem soars

February 19, 2021

EDITOR'S PICK

WagonBet Revolutionizes Online Betting through Innovatively Designed Platforms

WagonBet Revolutionizes Online Betting through Innovatively Designed Platforms

June 7, 2022
Algorand Boosts Smart Contract Performance With ‘Virtual Machine’ Launch — CoinDesk

Algorand Boosts Smart Contract Performance With ‘Virtual Machine’ Launch — CoinDesk

September 29, 2021
Big Institutions Are Eying Crypto. But Where Are the Inflows?

Big Institutions Are Eying Crypto. But Where Are the Inflows?

October 13, 2021
How Gensler Could Approach DeFi Enforcement

How Gensler Could Approach DeFi Enforcement

October 21, 2021

About

We publish a comprehensive news feed covering all news relevant to the crypto user, covering main industry news, politics and regulation as well as consumer-level “news you can use” (practical stuff), including handy DIY tips, links to useful tools, unbiased reviews and opinions revolving around cryptocurrency. Simple logic and real-world examples are preferred before technical jargon and personal rants.

Follow us

Categories

  • Altcoin
  • Bitcoin
  • Blockchain
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Ethereum
  • Litecoin
  • Market
  • Press Release
  • Regulation
  • Uncategorized

Recent Posts

  • Bitcoin miners are facing harsher conditions despite easier mining difficulty
  • US Infrastructure Law’s Reporting Requirements for Crypto Brokers Likely to Face Delay
  • Young Web3 Believers Unfazed by Battered Crypto Market
  • Real Time Strategy Battle of Insects Game Ookeenga to Launch NFT Collection on Binance NFT
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us

© 2020 cryptomustar.com

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Altcoin
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Litecoin
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Blockchain
  • Regulation
  • Market
  • Prices
  • ICO

© 2020 cryptomustar.com

  • YAM v2YAM v2(YAMV2)$4.70-1.41%
  • yfBetayfBeta(YFBETA)$4.27-0.10%
  • IDLEIDLE(IDLE)$1.44-12.39%
  • WPP TokenWPP Token(WPP)$0.006826-3.49%
  • DSLA ProtocolDSLA Protocol(DSLA)$0.003681-6.85%
  • lympoLympo(LYM)$0.004392-4.43%
  • Werewolf CoinWerewolf Coin(WWC)$0.098082-2.58%
  • PolkaBridgePolkaBridge(PBR)$0.439784-6.92%
  • Dev ProtocolDev Protocol(DEV)$1.76-16.14%
  • EvidenZEvidenZ(BCDT)$0.122949-3.85%